Showing posts with label memoir. Show all posts
Showing posts with label memoir. Show all posts

Saturday 11 June 2022

Manufactured History

Since History has become too incendiary to remain a scholarly discipline, it is now to be done by "public consultation" -- a bureaucratic phrase which borders on meaninglessness yet is laden with shadowy signaling.  

So what does the consulted public think about history? Which parts of the public are being consulted? Who are they being consulted by? Whoever it is, history will go on being itself, already having been itself. We can't change it, we can only either know or not know it. (Are schools still doing anything about knowing it?)

The agendum behind "doing history by public consultation" is to change the "narrative". If once deemed exclusive, privileged or unjust, a slice of history must be suppressed or rearranged, the previous chroniclers fired and a new crew taken aboard.

How is History by public consultation done then?                                                         

First you censor inconvenient documents, removing them from Public Archives.   

Then you remove awkward memoirs, history books and historical novels from public libraries.

You knock down statues and take portraits off walls.                               

You turn heritage buildings and historic houses into convention centres for anti-racism training and corrective re-education.                                                     

You change the school curriculum so as to cover indigenous history, "marginalized" and ethnic history, but not European, Anglo-Saxon, Enlightenment, Age of Reason and industrialization history. Students are taught by influencers, identity groups and therapists from the "correct" segments of the population.                                                                                                              Finally, you change the names of towns, parks, and streets so as to create amnesia about the figures they were originally named after, and the accomplishments for which those figures were commemorated.   

(WARNING for traditional scholarly historians: if you advance alternative non-consultative theories of the past you be may charged with Hate Speech.)



Seriously, the most reliable source of knowledge of past eras is well-written memoir (i.e. written by the literate): the "I was there and this is what I saw" genre.

For example: Daniel Defoe's A Tour Through the Whole Island of Great Britain" (1724-6) which meticulously described landscape and analyzed economic resources and social interaction, taking us there -- 18th century England. For example: 
"Dorchester is ... pleasant, agreeable ... the people seemed less divided into factions than in other places, for though not all of one mind, either as to religion or politics, yet did not separate with such animosity as in other places. I saw Church of England clergymen and the Dissenting minister drinking tea together, and conversing with civility and good neighbourhood ..."

Sounds like we today could learn a lot from their example ...

Too bad anyone recording today, and being read a hundred years from now, won't be able to say the same about our communities as Defoe said about Dorchester, riven as we are by identity politics and the desire not only to dispute the present but to re-package the past, fracturing it on the basis of rival "standpoints".

(Regarding the ancient past, as revealed in archaeology and text analysis, here's one example: the scholar Camille Jullian "devoted himself to classical antiquity and Roman Gaul. He reconstructed the history of this period by cross-referencing human geography, philology, numismatics, epigraphy and archaeology" and "strove to apply science and history to the teaching of the arts ... through thorough observation, research and analysis of anonymous archives.)  He lived 1859-1933. Does anyone still bother with those disciplines??



This story is reproduced from LITERARY YARD, www.literaryyard.com, 2024/02/10 It's a common fairy-tale theme -- imprisonment in a tower ...